|
BLEWP Papers
BLEWP Website
Policies
Search BLEWP
Submit a Paper
Notify me of new papers
|
 |

The Myth of International Delegation
Andrew T. Guzman, U.C. Berkeley School of Law, Boalt Hall
Jennifer Landsidle, Attorney-Adviser, U.S. Department of State
ABSTRACT: There is a growing and misinformed sense in some quarters that the United States and
other countries have engaged (and continue to engage) in delegations to international
institution that involve a significant threat to domestic sovereignty. Concerns about such
delegations come from academics (John Yoo: “Novel forms of international cooperation
increasingly call for the transfer of rulemaking authority to international organizations”),
prominent politicians (Bob Barr: “Nary a thought is given when international
organizations, like the UN, attempt to enforce their myopic vision of a one-world
government upon America, while trumping our Constitution in the process. Moreover,
many in our own government willfully or ignorantly cede constitutionally guaranteed
rights and freedoms to the international community;” Jesse Helms: “The American people see the UN aspiring to establish itself as the central authority of a new international order of global laws and global government.”); and senior government officials (John Bolton: “For virtually every area of public policy, there is a Globalist proposal, consistent with the overall objective of reducing individual nation-state autonomy, particularly that of the United States”).
In our view the perspective evidenced by the above quotes is almost wholly a myth. But it is a myth that persists and continues to attract attention. This Essay seeks to bring
forward a more realistic and accurate view of international institutions and engagement. We demonstrate that meaningful delegations of sovereignty are extremely rare and even when they do exist they are carefully cabined. Decision-making authority in all areas
remains firmly in the hands of national governments.
SUGGESTED CITATION: Andrew T. Guzman and Jennifer Landsidle,
"The Myth of International Delegation"
(April 7, 2008).
Berkeley Program in Law & Economics, Working Paper Series.
Paper 226.
http://repositories.cdlib.org/blewp/art226
|